Social Media

Showing posts with label breach of contract. Show all posts
Showing posts with label breach of contract. Show all posts

Thursday, February 26, 2015

Pick your Litigants Wisely When Filing Mechanic’s Lien Lawsuits

The Supreme Court of Virginia recently held that a subcontractor, Synchronized Construction Services, Inc. (“Synchronized”), could proceed with its mechanic’s lien lawsuit against the project owner and bank, despite the absence of the general contractor on the hotel construction project, finding that the general contractor was not a necessary party. In Synchronized Construction Services, Inc. v. Prav Lodging, LLC, et al., 764 S.E.2d 61 (Va. 2014), the subcontractor sought project amounts due with a breach of contract count against the general contractor (“GC”), and a mechanic’s lien count against the project owner and bank.

Synchronized failed to serve the GC in the litigation, and an appealable issue arose because the GC was not involved in the litigation of the mechanic’s lien claim. The circuit court held that because the GC was a necessary party, Synchronized’s mechanic’s lien claim could not proceed.

On appeal, the Supreme Court of Virginia focused its necessary party inquiry on the subject matter or the so-called “res” of the mechanic’s lien action.  Notably, the GC failed to perfect a mechanic’s lien on the project real estate. During the litigation, the owner and bank chose to go through a “bonding-off process” where they posted a bond, which had a practical effect of substituting the bond for the underlying project real estate – meaning that the res became the bond itself and not the real estate. The Court found that because the GC was not involved with its own lien and therefore had no rights to the underlying project real estate, and its rights were not tied up in any way with the posted bond, it had no specifically defined interest in the subject matter of the lawsuit, and was not a necessary party.

In light of this case, subs and other companies should ensure that they choose their parties wisely before proceeding with construction litigation. Failing to do so could derail an attempt to get a fair shake in court. The legal landscape is complicated and one slip can endanger a company’s entire payment claim.

Katie Lipp is an attorney with the Washington, DC regional business law firm Berenzweig Leonard, LLP, and the head of its construction law team. Katie can be reached at klipp@berenzweiglaw.com.


Friday, June 6, 2014

Virginia Courts Reject Fraud Claims Disguised as Breach of Contract Claims

A Virginia federal court recently confirmed that fraud claims seeking breach of contract damages are not allowable under Virginia law. This principle is referred to as the economic loss rule, and mandates that parties cannot “double-dip” and allege tort damages for contractual breaches in the form of fraud claims, on top of their breach of contract claims.

In other words, if you are choosing to accuse someone of fraud and breach of contract in Virginia, your lawsuit must be carefully drafted or you risk the loss of your fraud claim being dismissed at the outset of the case. Many parties fall into the trap of including as many counts as possible in their complaint, which can backfire, because if you are essentially seeking breach of contract damages with your fraud claim, such a claim will likely not survive.

The United States District Court for the Western District of Virginia, Roanoke Division recently confirmed  this principle in County of Grayson v. RA-Tech Services, Inc., 2014 WL2257155 (W.D. Va. May 29, 2014). Chief Judge Glen E. Conrad emphasized that constructive fraud claims need to specifically allege the time, place, and contents of the false statements, and preferably should include who made the fraudulent statements. The timing is critical for fraudulent inducement claims, because they must occur prior to any contract execution to stand alone and proceed past the motion to dismiss phase. The plaintiff’s constructive fraud claim failed to include the “time, place, and contents” details, and vaguely alleged that the defendant contracted with plaintiff with no intention of fulfilling its contractual responsibilities. The Western District found that it was essentially a breach of contract claim disguised as a fraud claim, dismissing plaintiff’s fraud in the inducement claim.

While many cases have viable contractual and tort claims, the construction law team at Berenzweig Leonard has experience with successfully defending our construction law clients against improper fraud claims, and preserving clients’ remedies for breach of contract and fraud.

Katie Lipp is an attorney with the Washington, DC regional business law firm Berenzweig Leonard, LLP. Katie can be reached at klipp@berenzweiglaw.com.